Evelyn Hartley: Shadow of Coincidence

itunes pic
Evelyn Grace Hartley was a 15 year old from LaCrosse, Wisconsin. She was a popular girl who didn’t mind studying on a Friday night. On October 24, 1953, she was babysitting for the first time at the home of the Rasmussen’s. At 8:30pm, Evelyn’s father called to see how she was doing. There was no answer. Worried, he drove over to see Evelyn and found the house had been broken into. Evelyn was gone. She was never seen again.

Anthony’s website:


Charley Project:




If you have any information regarding the disappearance of Evelyn Hartley, please contact the La Crosse Police Department at (608) 785-5962.

Unfound is on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, YouTube, iTunes, Podomatic, Stitcher, TuneInRadio, Podbean, and Overcast.
–And big announcement: Unfound is now on Spotify.
Email: Unfoundpodcast@gmail.com.
The website: Unfoundpodcast.com—please check out the secret Steven Koecher episode.
Amazon.com—Volume 1 in both ebook and print form. $2.99 and $10.99 respectively.
Patreon—you can start contributing to Unfound for as low as $2/month.
–Unfound also has a PayPal account.
And please mention Unfound on all true crime Facebook pages, and other websites and forums. Thank you.
Source: Unfound

Leave a Comment